• About Us
    • About the platform
    • Editorial Collective
  • Essays
    • Short Essays
    • Longer Reads
    • Reviews
    • Interviews
  • Series
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • World Press Photography Awards
  • Resources
  • Events and Calls
  • Art & multimedia
  • Contribute
  • About Us
    • About the platform
    • Editorial Collective
  • Essays
    • Short Essays
    • Longer Reads
    • Reviews
    • Interviews
  • Series
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • World Press Photography Awards
  • Resources
  • Events and Calls
  • Art & multimedia
  • Contribute
  • About Us
    • About the platform
    • Editorial Collective
  • Essays
    • Short Essays
    • Longer Reads
    • Reviews
    • Interviews
  • Series
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • World Press Photography Awards
  • Resources
  • Events and Calls
  • Art & multimedia
  • Contribute
Green Capital and Environmental “Leaders” Won’t Save Us
May 20, 2020
How new is the Green New Deal for the Global South?
May 26, 2020

In Defence of Blue Degrowth

Published by Undisciplined Environments on May 22, 2020

by Maria Hadjimichael* & Irmak Ertör**.

A recent special issue critically interrogates the rapidly expanding “Blue Growth” imperative – and proposes an alternative imaginary for the use of, access to, and social relations with the seas and oceans.

The publication of a “special feature” in Sustainability Science on Blue Degrowth and the Politics of the Sea: Rethinking the Blue Economy was mainly motivated by a deep frustration, a frustration that indicated the need to initiate such a debate. As (marine) social scientists and political ecologists, we have both been participating for a number of years in meetings on ocean governance and marine policies (such as for example meetings related to aquaculture, fisheries, marine protected areas etc.), organized by and with different actors such as the European Commission, Advisory Councils, and environmental NGOs, among others.

In all these events, what was striking was how the “growth imperative”, namely “Blue Growth” in marine discussions, was accepted as a given fact and as the discussion’s point zero. Even the most critical NGOs working on marine issues have been compliant to this narrative, promoted by powerful global actors (private, governmental or inter-governmental) as the “universal truth” and almost like a “common goal that unifies us all”. Though there has been some debate on the issue, it primarily focused on how to ensure growth in marine areas and how to make Blue Growth “sustainable”.

There was limited space to question the objectives of these policies. It rather seemed ridiculous and extreme to do so. It was more often than not, that we faced the shocked expression on the faces of politicians, policy-makers and private actors alike, whenever we suggested that seeking for continuous growth as a policy might perhaps be itself problematic, and that maybe the main objectives of the policies should be defined differently.

Since the European Commission’s Communication on Blue Growth opportunities for marine and maritime sustainable growth was published on 13 September 2012, Blue Growth has been the main header in almost all European marine circles. The Communication pointed out five main areas for Europe’s growth in the seas and oceans: (i) blue energy, (ii) aquaculture, (iii) maritime, coastal and cruise tourism, (iv) seabed mining, and (v) blue biotechnology.

Exposed to these debates, we felt that there was a need to have a serious confrontation with the Blue Growth imperative. As we discuss in the special feature’s editorial, Blue Growth has become an archetype among the different regional and international institutions and marine circles. However, there is not one agreed-upon definition. Some use the term to promote a new and more “participative” governance of seas and oceans, ignoring the failures of the extractivist mode of governance on land, whilst others take a more factual interpretation of the term, and focus on the profit-making potential of (new) marine sectors, and exploring further the potential of the marine space as an extractivist frontier.

Following the coining of the term in the 2018 article A call for a blue degrowth: Unravelling the European Union’s fisheries and maritime policies, we proposed to initiate this debate during the POLLEN18 Conference in Oslo, Norway. The conference became an important gathering with most of the authors of the special feature being part of a two-session panel on Blue Degrowth. It was evident that the critical marine social sciences were yet to engage the degrowth debates (and vice versa). Some panel discussions around the most common debates linked to degrowth (such as whether degrowth could be a useful term or slogan) were usually new for critical marine social scientists; conversely, engaging with the political ecology of marine issues was enriching for degrowth scholars and practitioners.

In the special feature, we argue that the Blue Growth imperative needs to be problematized and critically examined. Therefore, we use the concept Blue Degrowth, which emerges from (i) the need for confronting the new—but becoming rapidly dominant—“blue” growth imperative, and (ii) the quest for an alternative imaginary for the use of, access to, and social relations with the seas and oceans.

Blue Degrowth is thus a multifaceted concept, offering both a criticism to the Blue Growth imperative, and an umbrella concept to bring together the struggles of communities against concrete projects “on the ground”. It aims to guide the political discussions around the seas and oceans, as well as to uncover and contest its failures, injustices, and negative impacts, at different ecological, political, and social levels. While Blue Growth is at the centre of most current strategic and political marine discussions, Blue Degrowth intends to deconstruct the “win–win” argument of this imperative. It does so by building on degrowth debates and linking them with the element of the seas and oceans and by highlighting a range of struggles for social and ecological justice around the world.

Fisher people reclaiming their right to oceans on the Global Fisheries Day, 21 November 2017, in New Delhi, India (Photo credit: Irmak Ertör)

The special feature brings together 10 articles written by authors from different social science fields (such as geography, STS, ecological economics, political science and political ecology) with critical perspectives on marine issues and on the recent debates. Drawing on case studies of Iceland, Namibia, Turkey, and Papua New Guinea, among others, the articles critically examine different dimensions and strategies of Blue Growth and make a call for alternative imaginaries related to seas and oceans.

Links to the articles in the special feature are provided below:

Editorial: Blue degrowth and the politics of the sea: rethinking the blue economy by Irmak Ertör and Maria Hadjimichael

Growth in the docks: ports, metabolic flows and socio-environmental impacts by Borja Nogué-Algueró

The Blue Fix: What’s driving blue growth? by Zoe W. Brent, Mads Barbesgaard, Carsten Pedersen

Contesting growth in marine capture fisheries: the case of small-scale fishing cooperatives in Istanbul by Pınar Ertör-Akyazı

Swimming upstream: community economies for a different coastal rural development in Sweden by Milena Arias Schreiber, Ida Wingren and Sebastian Linke

The paradox of sustainable tuna fisheries in the Western Indian Ocean: between visions of blue economy and realities of accumulation by Mialy Andriamahefazafy, Megan Bailey, Hussain Sinan and Christian A. Kull

“Re-grabbing” marine resources: a blue degrowth agenda for the resurgence of small-scale fisheries in Malta by Alicia Said and Douglas MacMillan

Blue Growth and its discontents in the Faroe Islands: an island perspective on Blue (De)Growth, sustainability, and environmental justice by Ragnheiður Bogadóttir

Performing “blue degrowth”: critiquing seabed mining in Papua New Guinea through creative practice by John Childs

Lessons for blue degrowth from Namibia’s emerging blue economy by Rosanna Carver

Designing sustainability in blues: the limits of technospatial growth imaginaries by Duygu Kaşdoğan

 

** Maria Hadjimichael is a post-doctoral research fellow at the University of Cyprus. Her main research interests fall within the scope of environmental politics and the commons.

** Irmak Ertör is a former ENTITLE fellow and a political ecologist working on marine themes, especially on aquaculture, fisheries and environmental justice. Currently, she works as an assistant professor in the Bogazici University, Istanbul. 

 

Featured image: Collection of infographics on the Blue Growth and pictures of mobilisations for marine social and ecological justice, presented by Maria Hadjimichael and Irmak Ertör at the 2018 POLLEN conference in Oslo. Photo credit: Irmak Ertör.

Share
Undisciplined Environments
Undisciplined Environments

Related posts

March 24, 2022

Alternatives to mainstream publishing within and beyond academia


Read more

Illustration by Amanda Priebe.

March 15, 2022

Common Ecologies has launched!


Read more

Summer of our Power, 2015, by Climate Justice Alliance, part of their OurPower Campaign. See https://climatejusticealliance.org/2015-summer-of-our-power-just-transition-fellows/

August 3, 2021

Summer break note


Read more

1 Comment

  1. Elena Basilio Puig, Marguerite Culot - The Blue Side of (De)Growth - Brave New Europe says:
    November 5, 2021 at 12:04 am

    […] as coalitions of fishing communities and activists are reframing the debate through the lens of blue degradation and social justice. Organisations such as Seas At Risk have joined the discussion by advocating for […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search this site

✕

Subscribe to our Newsfeed

We keep your data private and share your data only with third parties that make this service possible. See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Tags

Agriculture Alternatives Anthropocene Art Brazil Capitalism Cities Climate change Climate crisis Climate justice Colonialism, Post-colonialism & Decolonization Commoning Commons Conflicts Conservation & Biodiversity COVID-19 Culture Decolonial Political Ecologies Degrowth Democracy Development Disaster Energy Environmental Change Environmental History Environmental Justice Environmental movements Extractivism Food Forests Green inequalities Indigenous Peoples Land Methodologies Mining & Extractivism Movements & Resistance Neoliberalism Post-colonialism Post-colonialism & Decolonization Social Movements & Resistance Urban Violence Waste Water water governance

Visit WEGO

wegoint.org
This website is co-funded by WEGO

Popular Posts

  • Far Right Ecologism and the Conceptual Deficiencies of Ecofascism 893 views
  • Women Vs. Mining: A Video Project 254 views
  • The dystopian world of the Handmaid’s tale 2/2 243 views
  • Indigenous Science 207 views
  • Seminar: “Energy Transitions from Below: From Climate Colonialism to Energy Sovereignty”, 15 June 202 views
  • A comprehensive political ecology reading list 179 views

Recent Comments

  • April 22, 2022

    Europe: Our Wounds Are Bridges – Global Dialogue for Systemic Change commented on Post-Extractive Futures (Workshop-Conversation-Festival)

  • April 21, 2022

    Podcast: The threads that bind us from Syria to Ukraine commented on Post-Extractive Futures (Workshop-Conversation-Festival)

  • April 10, 2022

    Undisciplined Environments commented on Colonial Climates, Decolonial Futures: Reflections from Puerto Rico

  • April 10, 2022

    Constanza V commented on Colonial Climates, Decolonial Futures: Reflections from Puerto Rico

  • April 6, 2022

    Colonial Ecologies of the Half Earth - Resilience commented on Political ecology gone wrong

  • April 6, 2022

    Colonial Ecologies of the Half Earth - Resilience commented on A conversation with Rob Nixon

Follow us

facebook       twitter
E-Mail Us : undisciplinedenvironments@gmail.com

Contribute

If you want to contribute send us your text at undisciplinedenvironments@gmail.com
Find our posting guide here

About Us

We are a collective of scholars and activists oriented towards a common horizon of emancipatory social and ecological transformation. With this platform, we aim to animate a space to share, debate and critically reflect on research and activist experiences, observations, methodologies, news, events, publications, art, music and other themes and objects related to political ecology.
powered by andromedia
  • About Us
  • Essays
  • Series
  • Resources
  • Events and Calls
  • Art & multimedia
  • Contribute
go