• About Us
    • About the platform
    • Editorial Collective
  • Essays
    • Short Essays
    • Longer Reads
    • Reviews
    • Interviews
  • Series
    • Italian Political Ecologies
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • World Press Photography Awards
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Political Ecologies of Pesticides
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • World Press Photography Awards
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
  • Resources
  • Events and Calls
  • Art & multimedia
  • Contribute
  • About Us
    • About the platform
    • Editorial Collective
  • Essays
    • Short Essays
    • Longer Reads
    • Reviews
    • Interviews
  • Series
    • Italian Political Ecologies
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • World Press Photography Awards
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Political Ecologies of Pesticides
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • World Press Photography Awards
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
  • Resources
  • Events and Calls
  • Art & multimedia
  • Contribute
  • About Us
    • About the platform
    • Editorial Collective
  • Essays
    • Short Essays
    • Longer Reads
    • Reviews
    • Interviews
  • Series
    • Italian Political Ecologies
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • World Press Photography Awards
    • Authoritarianism, populism and political ecology
    • Green inequalities in the city
    • Political Ecologies of Pesticides
    • Political Ecologies of the Far Right
    • Political Ecology for Civil Society
    • Ecomodernist socialism and comunist futurism
    • World Press Photography Awards
    • Ecology after Capitalism
    • Reimagining, remembering and reclaiming water
  • Resources
  • Events and Calls
  • Art & multimedia
  • Contribute
“Down with the fumes!” The Year of the Shootings and its relevance for mining today
March 5, 2018
Why are water wars back on the agenda? And why we think it’s a bad idea!
March 22, 2018

Tourism and Degrowth: Impossibility Theorem or Path to Post-Capitalism?

Published by Undisciplined Environments on March 8, 2018

by Robert Fletcher, Asunción Blanco-Romero, Macià Blázquez-Salom and Ivan Murray

“Touristification” of cities is increasingly met by discontent of local communities deprived of their places: overtourism is a real issue and we must face the challenge of rethinking and remaking one of the world’s biggest industries. The time has come to start talking seriously about how to bring tourism and degrowth together


Santa_Ponça_27_juliol_2009
Santa Ponca, Mallorca. Photo by Macià Blázquez-Salom.

A spectre is haunting tourism: the spectre of degrowth.

Recent years have witnessed mounting discontent with the impacts of tourism growth in some of the world’s most popular destinations. Such reactions address several common impacts of tourism expansion.

On the one hand, growth in mass tourism increases pressure on existing spaces while continually colonizing new ones. Meanwhile, efforts to combat this by redirecting the industry towards more exclusive high-income tourism segregates spaces from locals entirely.

Combined, these dynamics are transforming formerly multi-functional cities into “monocultural” tourist resorts. State officials have generally not offered adequate legal responses to this situation. And even when local authorities ​​have proposed palliative measures (as in Barcelona, via a regulatory framework called PEUAT) these are rarely strong enough to confront the extent of the problem.

This complacency has prompted increasingly intense responses from civil society, including claims that “tourism kills the city” and calls for de-touristified spaces or even “tourist free zones.”

In Barcelona, the Assemblea de Barris per un Turisme Sostemible (Catalan for “Assembly of Neighborhoods for a Sustainable Tourism,” or ABTS) has united numerous community groups in organizing actions to challenge mass tourism development. In Mallorca, which receives more than 11 million visitors per year, Ciutat per qui l’Habita (Catalan for “The City for the Dwellers”) struggles against the touristification and “airbnbification” of every corner of the island, where people suffer from evictions and other tourism-related violence.

Similar initiatives have ignited in many other cities including Amsterdam, Madrid and Venice.

IMG_1530

Residents protesting unregulated tourism in Mallorca. Photo by Marc Morell.

From Tourism-phobia to Overtourism and Beyond

The extent of this unrest is such that it has captured the attention of some powerful industry actors including the United Nations World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) and the World Travel and Tourism Council (WTTC). Such attention displays a marked ambivalence.

On the one hand, expressions of discontent concerning tourism development are commonly dismissed as “tourism-phobia.” Yet at the same time, industry insiders have started to acknowledge the possibility that some destinations may indeed be experiencing what they call “overtourism.”

Within this discussion, no industry proponents mention “degrowth” specifically. Indeed, UNWTO is at pains to claim that “growth is not the enemy; it is how we manage it.”

But social movements contesting aspects of tourism development have indeed begun to explicitly employ this label. In Barcelona, for instance, ABTS calls for “decreixement turístic” (Catalan for “touristic degrowth”).

This raise intriguing questions concerning the relationship between such discussions and a more general degrowth movement that has gained significant attention in recent years. Despite the fact that Barcelona is also one of the main nodes of this larger movement, however, there has been little systematic effort thus far to connect degrowth discussion with tourism specifically.

For those of us who study tourism for a living, this is not entirely surprising. Many consider it a frivolous activity not worthy of serious study. Yet tourism is arguably one of the world’s largest industries. Serious pursuit of degrowth on a global scale, therefore, should demand that the practice be given serious consideration as well.

Platja_de_Palma_28_july_2009

Platja de Palma, Mallorca. Photos by Macià Blázquez-Salom.

An Impossibility Theorem?

The significance of tourism for degrowth comprises an additional important dimension. Eco-Marxist John Bellamy Foster asserts that degrowth within a capitalist economy is an “impossibility theorem” given that capitalism requires continual growth to manage internal contradictions that would otherwise threaten its survival.  From this perspective, serious degrowth requires challenging some of the fundamental tenets of capitalist economics.

As one of the world’s largest industries, tourism can also be understood as one of the main means by which the capitalist system as a whole maintains the expansion that sustains it. Indeed, the significance of tourism in this regard is difficult to overemphasize.

The tourism “industry,” after all, is really an amalgamation of various other industries and processes – from food service to transport to hospitality to advertising to real estate to speculative finance – centered around the movement of people for purposes of leisure. In addition, tourism intersects with many other auxiliary industries and markets to which it offers a significant “multiplier effect.”

The contribution of tourism to capitalist expansion and sustenance thus exceeds even its own formidable dimensions, comprising a web whose strands extend throughout the world in myriad forms. At the same time, consequently, a different form of tourism – one that departs from the capitalist growth imperative – might serve as an important “post-capitalist” practice with potential to transform dramatically this same global web.

It should be noted that advocacy of tourism degrowth is not anti-tourism. It calls for tourism to be organized and practiced in a different way, and at a different scale, to avoid many of the industry’s negative impacts – economic, social and environmental – and instead maximize benefits to local communities and ecosystems.

IMG_1511

Residents protesting unregulated tourism in Mallorca. Photo by Marc Morell.

Conclusion: In Pursuit of Detourism?

So what would such a form of tourism degrowth – or what we might call simply “detourism” – look like? There are a wide variety of initiatives in discussion or development that can be seen as potential elements, from calls for steady state and slow tourism to promotion of staycations to efforts to “green” touristic infrastructure including air transport and electricity production. The question of how all of this might be brought together and “scaled up” into a coherent, post-capitalist detourism proposal, however, has just begun to enter the conversation.

As part of a larger research collective, in the years to follow we hope to contribute to this conversation, first with a special theme issue of the Journal of Sustainable Tourism that we are currently assembling and then with a collaborative programme to investigate movements to redirect tourism development in a variety of “mature” tourism destinations in Southern Europe and elsewhere. This will be preceded by a panel session on Tourism and Degrowth at the POLLEN 2018 conference in Oslo, Norway, 20-22 June.

In the meantime, we offer this initial discussion as an invitation to others to enter the conversation as well.

Detourists of the world unite! You have nothing to lose but your growth!

Robert Fletcher is associate professor in the Sociology of Development and Change group at Wageningen University in the Netherlands.
Asunción Blanco-Romero is professor of Geography at Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona in Spain.
Macià Blázquez-Salom is professor of Geography at Universitat de les Illes Balears in Spain.
Ivan Murray is an assistant lecturer in Geography at Universitat de les Illes Balears in Spain.
 

Share
Undisciplined Environments
Undisciplined Environments

Related posts

March 21, 2023

Under-ground ore: street intervention in the face of socio-environmental devastation in the Quintero-Puchuncaví sacrifice zone


Read more
March 7, 2023

South-South Circles of Poison? Malaysia’s role in (re)creating uneven geographies


Read more
January 10, 2023

Biodiversity breakthrough or time to stop global environmental meetings altogether?


Read more

8 Comments

  1. katharinehowell says:
    March 8, 2018 at 2:04 pm

    Reblogged this on Political Ecology Network.

    Reply
  2. Jorge Carrillo says:
    March 9, 2018 at 4:02 am

    Reblogged this on Reading Development.

    Reply
  3. 1weaver says:
    March 9, 2018 at 8:06 am

    following with interest from paphos, cyprus…

    Reply
  4. Turisme i decreixement: Teorema impossible o camí al postcapitalisme? | Assemblea de Barris per un Turisme Sostenible (ABTS) says:
    March 16, 2018 at 8:30 am

    […] article es va publicar prèviament en anglès en el Bloc Entitle el 8 de març de […]

    Reply
  5. April monthly newsfeed | Political Ecology Network says:
    April 5, 2018 at 6:15 pm

    […] Tourism and Degrowth: Impossibility Theorem or Path to Post-Capitalism? by Robert Fletcher, Asunción Blanco-Romero, Macià Blázquez-Salom and Ivan Murray […]

    Reply
  6. Tourism and Degrowth: Impossibility Theorem or Path to Post-Capitalism? – Mass Tourism says:
    May 10, 2018 at 1:58 pm

    […] on 8 March 2018 by entitlecollective @ https://entitleblog.org/ “Touristification” of cities is increasingly met by discontent of local communities deprived […]

    Reply
  7. Tourism, Degrowth and the COVID-19 Crisis – Undisciplined Environments says:
    April 16, 2020 at 2:59 pm

    […] as part of a degrowth transition more broadly. We highlighted this discussion in a previous blog post as well as a special issue of the Journal of Sustainable Tourism republished as an edited […]

    Reply
  8. Tourism, capitalism, & the coronavirus crisis: What is to be (un)done? – Indiatips.in says:
    September 7, 2021 at 8:30 am

    […] How­ever, by admon­ish­ing tour­ism busi­nesses and nation­al tour­ism organ­isa­tions to ‘lead’ the change to ensure “enter­prises deliv­er net pos­it­ive impacts to the places and soci­ety in which they oper­ate”, its advoc­ates under­play the neces­sity of con­front­ing the deep-seated roots of capitalism’s social and eco­lo­gic­al con­tra­dic­tions. […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search this site

✕

Subscribe to our Newsfeed

We keep your data private and share your data only with third parties that make this service possible. See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Tags

Agriculture Alternatives Anthropocene Art Brazil Capitalism Cities Climate change Climate crisis Climate justice Colonialism, Post-colonialism & Decolonization Commoning Commons Conflicts Conservation & Biodiversity COVID-19 Culture Decolonial Political Ecologies Degrowth Democracy Development Disaster Energy Environmental Change Environmental History Environmental Justice Environmental movements Extractivism Food Forests Green inequalities Indigenous Peoples Land Methodologies Mining & Extractivism Movements & Resistance Neoliberalism Post-colonialism Post-colonialism & Decolonization Social Movements & Resistance Urban Violence Waste Water water governance

Visit WEGO

wegoint.org
This website is co-funded by WEGO

Popular Posts

  • Indigenous Science 292 views
  • South-South Circles of Poison? Malaysia’s role in (re)creating uneven geographies 141 views
  • What does virtual water conceal? 121 views
  • A comprehensive political ecology reading list 98 views
  • Weaving musical spaces of indigenous resistance for environmental justice 85 views
  • Venice Climate March, September 10, 2022. Credits: Michele Lapini From overlapping to convergence: workers’ struggles and climate justice from GKN, Florence 80 views

Recent Comments

  • February 9, 2023

    About refrigerators – Thoughts in words commented on About refrigerators

  • February 5, 2023

    Luciano medinero morales commented on Fruta saludable, cuerpos enfermos

  • January 29, 2023

    User19 commented on Green is the new brown: ecology in the metapolitics of the far right

  • January 26, 2023

    Book review: “Enlightenment and Ecology: The Legacy of Murray Bookchin in the 21st Century” – towardsautonomyblog commented on Social Ecology, Kurdistan, and the Origins of Freedom

  • January 25, 2023

    المدن المستدامة بعد COVID-19: هل المناطق الخضراء على غرار برشلونة هي الحل؟ - Corepaedia news commented on To Green Or Not To Green: Four stories of urban (in)justice in Barcelona

  • January 4, 2023

    Timo commented on Against the misrepresentation of climate activism in Lützerath aka the ZAD Rhineland

✕

Tags

Agriculture Alternatives Anthropocene Art Brazil Capitalism Cities Climate change Climate crisis Climate justice Colonialism, Post-colonialism & Decolonization Commoning Commons Conflicts Conservation & Biodiversity COVID-19 Culture Decolonial Political Ecologies Degrowth Democracy Development Disaster Energy Environmental Change Environmental History Environmental Justice Environmental movements Extractivism Food Forests Green inequalities Indigenous Peoples Land Methodologies Mining & Extractivism Movements & Resistance Neoliberalism Post-colonialism Post-colonialism & Decolonization Social Movements & Resistance Urban Violence Waste Water water governance

Follow us

facebook       twitter
E-Mail Us : undisciplinedenvironments@gmail.com

Contribute

If you want to contribute send us your text at undisciplinedenvironments@gmail.com
Find our posting guide here

About Us

We are a collective of scholars and activists oriented towards a common horizon of emancipatory social and ecological transformation. With this platform, we aim to animate a space to share, debate and critically reflect on research and activist experiences, observations, methodologies, news, events, publications, art, music and other themes and objects related to political ecology.
powered by andromedia
  • About Us
  • Essays
  • Series
  • Resources
  • Events and Calls
  • Art & multimedia
  • Contribute
go